
Prices checked November 20, 2026.
The most valuable 1989 Fleer baseball cards are the rare white-out versions of the Bill Ripken error card, which have sold for $4,900 to $11,750 in PSA 10, and the Ken Griffey Jr. rookie from the Glossy tin set, which sells for about $8,000 in PSA 10. After those come the clear Randy Johnson “Marlboro” rookie at about $1,450 and the original Ripken error at about $875. Below is the top 10, ranked by the most recent PSA 10 sale, with a link to the source for every price.
The 660-card 1989 Fleer set is a junk wax staple, but it has more going for it than most sets from the era: rookie cards of five Hall of Famers or stars (Ken Griffey Jr., Randy Johnson, Craig Biggio, John Smoltz and Gary Sheffield), two famous errors, and a low-print Glossy version sold in tins. The regular cards are worth very little unless they grade a 10.
The most valuable 1989 Fleer cards
| # | Card | Latest PSA 10 sale | Date | Where |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bill Ripken #616 “Whited Out Vulgarity” | $11,750 | Nov 7, 2025 | eBay (reported by Sports Illustrated) |
| 2 | Ken Griffey Jr. #548 Glossy (rookie) | $8,000 | Nov 1, 2026 | Fanatics Collect |
| 3 | Bill Ripken #616 “Scribbled Out in White” | $4,915.87 | Feb 2025 | eBay |
| 4 | Randy Johnson #381 “Marlboro Ad on Scoreboard” (rookie) | $1,450 | Nov 13, 2026 | Fanatics Collect |
| 5 | Bill Ripken #616 “Black Scribble Over Error” | $1,026.50 | Nov 13, 2026 | eBay |
| 6 | Bill Ripken #616 “FF Error” (original) | $876 | Nov 16, 2026 | eBay |
| 7 | Randy Johnson #381 Glossy, ad blacked out (rookie) | $750 | Nov 5, 2026 | Fanatics Collect |
| 8 | Ken Griffey Jr. #548 (rookie) | $383 | Nov 16, 2026 | eBay |
| 9 | Randy Johnson #381 “Ad Partially Obscured” (rookie) | $299.99 | Nov 14, 2026 | eBay |
| 10 | Bill Ripken #616 “Black Box Over Error” | $105.59 | Nov 18, 2026 | eBay |
For the rest of the decade, see the most valuable 1980s baseball cards, and for every Griffey rookie, see the most iconic Ken Griffey Jr. rookie cards.
#616 Bill Ripken: the “F Face” error and its fixes
The most famous error card of the junk wax era. On the original card, an obscenity is clearly written on the knob of Bill Ripken’s bat. In a 2008 interview with CNBC, Ripken said he’d written it himself to mark a batting practice bat so he could find it quickly, and never thought about it when he posed for the photo. Fleer noticed after the cards were already out and fixed it on the press several times, which is why there are so many versions. Price guides and PSA’s labels recognize five, but collectors track a dozen or more small differences.
| Version (PSA label) | What it looks like | Raw | PSA 9 | PSA 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| “FF Error” | The original, with the words readable | About $74 | About $215 | $811 to $955 |
| “Whited Out Vulgarity” | Knob painted over in solid white | About $465 | $2,500 | $11,750 (Nov 2025) |
| “Scribbled Out in White” | White scribble over the words | About $1,000 | $2,599 | $4,915.87 (Feb 2025) |
| “Black Scribble Over Error” | Black marker-style scribble | About $34 | About $115 to $135 | About $960 to $1,100 |
| “Black Box Over Error” | Black box over the knob (the final fix) | About $4 | About $35 | About $105 |
The original “F Face” error

The one everyone knows. It’s not rare (tens of thousands have been graded) but it’s the one people want, and a PSA 10 sells for $811 to $955.
White versions: “Scribbled Out in White” and “Whited Out Vulgarity”


These are the valuable ones: short-lived fixes with only a few hundred graded in any grade. Some collectors, including the fan site billripken.com, have questioned whether every whited-out copy is genuine, so if you’re paying real money for one, buy it graded. Some collectors also track a “circle scribble” version, which PSA doesn’t label separately.

Black Scribble and Black Box


The black scribble is cheap raw but sells for around $1,000 in PSA 10. The black box was Fleer’s final fix and is the most common version, worth about $4 raw.
Watch out: the black and white “test run” is fake


These black and white “test run” cards are novelty fakes printed on photo paper. They still sell for $20 to $50 on eBay, usually labelled as counterfeits. Don’t pay more.
The 1989 Fleer Glossy set
Fleer also sold the whole set as a glossy factory set in a tin, its answer to Topps Tiffany. It was the last year Fleer did it, and the print run is estimated at about 30,000 sets, far fewer than the regular cards. The Glossy cards have a shiny front and blue ink on the back. They’re where the real money is for the non-error cards: the Glossy Griffey rookie sells for about $8,000 in PSA 10, against about $380 for the regular one, and the Glossy Randy Johnson about $750.
#548 Ken Griffey Jr. rookie
Griffey’s Fleer rookie is about $4 raw, $35 to $47 in PSA 9 and $350 to $425 in PSA 10 (November 2026). Thousands of PSA 10s exist, so the regular version stays affordable. It’s one of several Griffey rookies from 1989; the Upper Deck #1 is the famous one.
#381 Randy Johnson rookie: the Marlboro ad
Randy Johnson’s rookie shows a Marlboro billboard on the outfield scoreboard behind him. Fleer covered it up partway through the print run, so there are three main versions, plus tinted ones that a few collectors chase.
Marlboro ad on scoreboard (clear)

The scarce one, with the ad clearly readable. About $95 raw, $329 in PSA 9 and $1,450 to $1,675 in PSA 10.
Ad partially obscured

About $18 raw and about $300 in PSA 10.
Ad completely blacked out

The common version: about $2 raw and about $60 in PSA 10.
Other 1989 Fleer cards worth checking
The rest of the set’s stars sell for a dollar or two raw. In PSA 10 they’re worth more, and the Glossy versions more again:
- #368 Nolan Ryan: about $60 to $70 in PSA 10. Glossy about $140 to $185.
- #602 John Smoltz (rookie): about $30 to $35 in PSA 10. Glossy about $120.
- #285 Bo Jackson: about $85 to $100 in PSA 10. Glossy about $200.
- #353 Craig Biggio (rookie): about $35 in PSA 10. Glossy about $115.
- #196 Gary Sheffield (rookie): about $40 in PSA 10. Glossy about $180 to $210.
- #5 Jose Canseco and #325 Will Clark: about $40 in PSA 10.
- #173 Jeff Treadway “Target” error: a small target is printed above his head. Raw copies sell for about $46 and a PSA 9 for about $120.






Thinking about grading one? My grading calculator shows whether the fee is worth it at these prices.
FAQ
How much is a 1989 Fleer Bill Ripken card worth?
It depends on the version. The original “F Face” error is about $75 raw and $811 to $955 in PSA 10. The common black box fix is about $4 raw and $105 in PSA 10. The two white-out versions are the valuable ones: about $465 to $1,000 raw, and $4,900 to $11,750 in PSA 10.
What is the most valuable 1989 Fleer card?
The Bill Ripken “Whited Out Vulgarity” variation, which sold for $11,750 in PSA 10 in November 2025. The most valuable card that isn’t an error is the Glossy Ken Griffey Jr. rookie, at about $8,000 in PSA 10.
How many 1989 Fleer Bill Ripken variations are there?
Five main ones on price guides and PSA labels: the original error, Whited Out, Scribbled Out in White, Black Scribble and Black Box. There’s also a Glossy black box version, and collectors track a dozen or more smaller differences.
Is the 1989 Fleer Randy Johnson Marlboro card rare?
The version with the ad clearly visible is: it’s the scarcest of the three, and sells for about $1,450 in PSA 10. The blacked-out version is common and sells for about $60 in PSA 10.
How much is a 1989 Fleer Ken Griffey Jr. rookie worth?
About $4 raw, about $40 in PSA 9 and about $350 to $425 in PSA 10. The Glossy version is worth about $8,000 in PSA 10.
