The Indianapolis area has 37 card shops from downtown out to Carmel, Noblesville, Avon, Greenwood and Greenfield. The Game Preserve has been in the city since 1980, Indy Card Exchange since 1990 and The Dugout since 1997, and CardVault by Tom Brady opened near Lucas Oil Stadium in September 2026. Each listing has the address, hours, what the shop sells and whether it buys cards, grouped by area.
Jump to: Downtown and central Indianapolis · North side Indianapolis · Carmel, Fishers and Noblesville · West side and Hendricks County · South side, Greenwood and Franklin · East side, Greenfield and Anderson · Card shows
Driving to or through Indianapolis? Plan a route through card shops on the way with our trip planner.
Downtown and central Indianapolis
CardVault by Tom Brady
2 N Meridian St, Indianapolis 46204
The chain's 19th store opened on September 27, 2026, a short walk from Lucas Oil Stadium and Gainbridge Fieldhouse. It takes PSA, Beckett and SGC grading submissions and has a case of signed memorabilia.
Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby
1354 Shelby St Ste A, Indianapolis 46203 · (317) 600-3313
A veteran-owned game tavern in Fountain Square with free play tables and beer. Board games and RPGs come first here, with Magic events on the side.
Good Games Indianapolis
111 S Meridian St, Indianapolis 46225 · (317) 493-1423
Hours: Mon-Thu 11 AM-9 PM, Fri-Sat 11 AM-10 PM, Sun 11 AM-9 PM
The Indianapolis branch of the Good Games chain, on South Meridian Street downtown. It sells Magic singles and sealed product and posts a weekly event calendar for Magic, Pokémon and One Piece.
Paradigm Games
2479 N Meridian St, Indianapolis 46208 · (715) 379-6831
Hours: Tue-Fri 2-10 PM, Sat-Sun noon-5 PM, Mon closed
A Magic and Pokémon shop on North Meridian near the Children's Museum. It runs a buylist at the counter, keeps its singles on a TCGplayer storefront, and holds Commander on Tuesday and Thursday and Pokémon League on Sunday.
North side Indianapolis
Game Time
8244 Center Run Dr, Indianapolis 46250 · (317) 577-0900
Hours: Mon-Thu noon-8 PM, Fri noon-10 PM, Sat 10 AM-8 PM, Sun closed
A Magic-focused store near Castleton that takes singles orders through a form on its site for pickup in the shop.
Gamer's Loot
6020 E 82nd St, Indianapolis 46250 · (317) 443-3133
A game store inside Castleton Square mall, by the JCPenney entrance. Its staff taught a Magic: The Gathering 101 class for teens at the West Indianapolis library branch in August 2026.
Gray Gauntlet Games
7998 Centerpoint Dr Ste 750, Indianapolis 46256 · (317) 559-3676
A game store near the Fishers line, founded in 2016. It posts a buylist and takes bulk Magic and Pokémon submissions, and also stocks Flesh and Blood and Warhammer.
Indy Card Exchange
7035 E 96th St Ste P, Indianapolis 46250 · (317) 254-8681
Hours: Tue-Thu 10 AM-6 PM, Fri 10 AM-7 PM, Sat 10 AM-5 PM, Sun noon-5 PM, Mon closed
Open since 1990 and a PSA Authorized Dealer, so it can send cards to PSA for you. It also runs a Kids Club and does custom framing.
The Game Preserve (Fashion Mall)
8487 Union Chapel Rd Ste 660, Indianapolis 46240 · (317) 257-9110
Hours: Mon-Sat 10 AM-9 PM, Sun noon-6 PM
A board game store that has been in Indianapolis since 1980. Magic and Pokémon are a smaller part of the shelves, with events in the play space.
Carmel, Fishers and Noblesville
Atomic Planet Comics
8906 E 96th St, Fishers 46037 · (317) 588-9139
Hours: Mon-Tue noon-6 PM, Wed-Fri 10 AM-8 PM, Sat 10 AM-6 PM, Sun closed
A comic shop on 96th Street that also hosts casual Commander nights and Pokémon learn-to-play days.
Collectors Emporium
17681 Cumberland Rd, Noblesville 46060 · (317) 995-4798
A family-owned shop that sells Pokémon and One Piece singles and slabs alongside comics and vinyl records. Its site sells tickets and dealer spots for Collectors Palooza at the State Fairgrounds.
Hero's Emporium
12697 N Pennsylvania St Ste 120, Carmel 46032 · (317) 575-1737
A Carmel game store on North Pennsylvania Street that changed owners in 2017. Wizards lists it as a Magic store, and it also runs Warhammer events.
Moonshot Games
50 N 9th St, Noblesville 46060 · (317) 662-2889
Hours: Mon-Thu 10 AM-9 PM, Fri 10 AM-10 PM, Sat 10 AM-9 PM, Sun 10 AM-6 PM
A WPN Premium store on the Noblesville square. It sells Magic and Pokémon singles online and in store and opens product on its Moonshot Rips live stream.
Next Level Games Carmel
14560 River Rd Ste 130, Carmel 46033 · (765) 717-0697
Hours: Mon noon-8 PM, Tue-Thu noon-10 PM, Fri-Sat noon-midnight, Sun noon-10 PM
The Carmel branch of a Muncie game store, on River Road. It stays open until midnight on Friday and Saturday and has its own buylist, separate from the Muncie store's.
Play Test Lounge
1776 E 116th St, Carmel 46032 · (317) 650-8547
Hours: Sun-Thu 11 AM-10 PM, Fri 11 AM-11 PM, Sat 10 AM-11 PM
A gaming lounge on 116th Street that sells singles for several games, including Riftbound and Flesh and Blood, and is open until 10 PM or later every night.
West side and Hendricks County
Best Card Shop
2030 Stafford Rd, Plainfield 46168 · (317) 203-5578
Hours: Tue-Sat noon-8 PM, Sun 10 AM-2 PM, Mon closed
A Plainfield sports card shop that sells hobby boxes for baseball, football, basketball, UFC and WWE and runs its own Best Card Breaks.
Bulldog Community Gaming
1060 E Main St Ste 302, Brownsburg 46112 · (317) 286-3467
A community game store on Main Street in Brownsburg that posts a weekly calendar of card game events.
Conquest Cards
7483 E US Hwy 36 Ste B, Avon 46123 · (317) 829-1102
Hours: Fri-Sat 11 AM-8 PM, Sun 11 AM-6 PM, Mon-Thu closed
A weekend-only card shop on US 36 in Avon. Directory listings show it open Friday to Sunday only.
Indy Card Shop
2346 S Lynhurst Dr Ste 706, Indianapolis 46241 · (317) 207-0187
A small Pokémon shop in a Lynhurst Drive plaza near the airport, with packs, boxes and a run of singles.
k0s Card Shop
8100 E US Hwy 36 Ste Q, Avon 46123 · (317) 707-7050
Hours: Tue-Fri 2-8 PM, Sat noon-7 PM, Sun 1-5 PM, Mon closed
A TCG shop that runs a three-season Pokémon league with its own championship. It buys cards at set times, not on Sundays, and sells what you need to send cards for grading yourself.
Moonshot Games (Plainfield)
1620 E Main St Ste 151, Plainfield 46168 · (317) 742-7401
Moonshot's second store, which Wizards lists as a Premium store. It shares the Noblesville store's online singles stock and event calendar.
The Dugout
5707 W Morris St, Indianapolis 46241 · (317) 247-5158
Open since November 1997 and owned by James McWhorter. It mixes basketball, football and baseball cards with a TCG side that has at least one tournament or league night every week.
Vintage Indy Sports
1450 N Main St Ste B, Speedway 46224 · (317) 910-7650
A Speedway memorabilia store focused on Indiana high school basketball, the Colts, Pacers, IU, Purdue and Notre Dame, with vintage cards in all four major sports.
South side, Greenwood and Franklin
A&A Games
1910 Northwood Plaza Dr, Franklin 46131 · (317) 868-8036
A game and card store in Franklin's Northwood Plaza. Wizards lists it as a Magic store.
Cards and Castles Tabletop Shop
400 Tracy Rd Ste 4, New Whiteland 46184 · (317) 560-2053
A tabletop shop between Greenwood and Franklin that runs Pokémon on Sunday afternoons and buys and sells used board games.
Fan Cave Indy
4805 Madison Ave, Indianapolis 46227 · (317) 426-4921
Owned by Parker and Jack Stevens, this shop sorts its cards by player and sport. Colts cards sell best, and it holds Midnight Madness trade nights a few times a year.
Game World
7625 Shelby St, Indianapolis 46227 · (317) 300-1070
The Indianapolis branch of a Bloomington game store, next door to Mage's on Shelby Street. It also sells Pokémon cards.
Grandmaster Games
4200 S East St, Indianapolis 46227 · (463) 271-0560
Hours: Mon noon-7 PM, Tue-Wed noon-9:30 PM, Thu noon-7 PM, Fri noon-9:30 PM, Sat-Sun 11 AM-7 PM
A south side TCG store on South East Street known for its pull-list singles system and a busy Pokémon league night.
K & L Cards
3100 Meridian Parke Dr Ste Z, Greenwood 46142 · (317) 883-2240
Hours: Mon 10 AM-7 PM, Tue 10 AM-6 PM, Wed-Thu 10 AM-7 PM, Fri 10 AM-8 PM, Sat 10 AM-7 PM, Sun noon-6 PM
A Greenwood shop that has been selling cards for about 30 years, in the Meridian Parke center at Fairview Road and State Road 135. It buys, sells and trades rookies, autographs and memorabilia cards.
Mage's Comics and Games
7623 Shelby St, Indianapolis 46227 · (930) 203-3624
Hours: Mon-Sat 10 AM-8 PM, Sun noon-5 PM
A comic shop on Shelby Street that also carries Magic, One Piece and Pokémon.
Southside Sports Cards
3825 S East St, Indianapolis 46227 · (317) 649-6866
A sports card shop on South East Street that keeps its updates on Facebook.
The Game Preserve (Southside)
1551 E Stop 12 Rd Ste B, Indianapolis 46227 · (317) 881-4263
The Game Preserve's second store, just south of Greenwood Park Mall. It has a large play space and an active Magic group.
Ye Gamer's Guild
2801 Fairview Pl Ste I, Greenwood 46142 · (317) 743-8449
A Greenwood game store with play tables and a snack bar. Wizards lists it as a Magic store.
East side, Greenfield and Anderson
Four Sharp Corners
218 E Main St, Greenfield 46140 · (317) 462-9238
Hours: Mon-Fri 10:30 AM-6 PM, Sat 10 AM-5 PM, Sun closed
A sports card shop on Main Street in downtown Greenfield.
Hometown Comics & Games
1040 N State St, Greenfield 46140 · (317) 467-9050
Hours: Mon-Thu 11 AM-8 PM, Fri 11 AM-9 PM, Sat 11 AM-8 PM, Sun 11 AM-6 PM
A comic and game store on State Street in Greenfield with comics, manga, board games and card games.
Saltire Toys & Games
11135 Pendleton Pike Ste 1200, Indianapolis 46236 · (317) 823-1645
A toy and game store on Pendleton Pike near Lawrence. Pokémon, Magic and Flesh and Blood sit beside board games and toys.
The Gamers Vault
1417 E 53rd St, Anderson 46013 · (765) 623-1040
A game store on East 53rd Street in Anderson, a few blocks from The Danger Room. Wizards lists it as a Magic store.
Shop details checked October 2026. Hours change, so check with the shop before you go.
Indianapolis card shows
Collectors Palooza, which used to be Pokepalooza, fills a building at the State Fairgrounds once a month with Pokémon, One Piece and Lorcana tables. Sports card shows run most weekends in Legion halls in Fishers, Carmel and Greenwood, and the Rift TCG show on Holt Road is a Sunday TCG show with free general admission. Dates move, so check each show’s site before you go.
- Collectors Palooza Next: Oct 17-18 · Indiana State Fairgrounds & Event Center, Ag/Hort Building, Indianapolis. Formerly Pokepalooza, with 250 or more tables of Pokémon, One Piece and Lorcana. Hours are 9 AM to 5 PM with early-bird entry at 9 and general admission at 11. Parking at the fairgrounds is $10.
- Franklin Sports Card Show Next: Oct 17 · Johnson County Shrine Club, 751 W King St, Franklin. A free Saturday show from 10 AM to 3 PM.
- JJ All Star Sportscards Show Next: Oct 17 · American Legion Post 470, 9091 E 126th St, Fishers. Jeff Meyrose's monthly Saturday show, 8 AM to 2 PM, with free admission. The same promoter runs the larger Midwest Monster shows.
- Southside Sports Card Show Next: Oct 18 · American Legion Post 252, 334 US 31 S, Greenwood. A Sunday show at the Greenwood Legion from 10 AM to 3:30 PM.
- Carmel Sports Card Show Next: Oct 23-24 · American Legion Post 155, 852 W Main St, Carmel. A free Saturday show from 9 AM to 3 PM. The October 23 and 24 dates are the show's two-year anniversary and move to the Aletto Family Sports Center.
- Rift TCG Card Show Next: Oct 25 · American Legion Post 64, 601 S Holt Rd, Indianapolis. A Sunday TCG show on the west side. VIP entry is $10 at 10 AM and general admission is free from 11 AM to 5 PM. The October 25 date is a Halloween edition.
- Card Show at The Eyrie Next: Nov 1 · The Eyrie Event Center, 115 W Main St, Plainfield. A free, locally run Sunday show in downtown Plainfield, 10 AM to 3 PM.
- Indy Sports Card Show Next: Nov 7 · La Quinta Inn, 5120 Victory Dr, Indianapolis. A Saturday hotel show on the southeast side, 8 AM to 2 PM.
- Carmel Pokémon Show Next: Nov 22 · American Legion Post 155, 852 W Main St, Carmel. The Sunday companion to the Carmel Sports Card Show, in the same Legion hall from 9 AM to 3 PM.
- Noblesville Card Show Next: Dec 12 · Noblesville Moose Lodge #540, 950 Field Dr, Noblesville. A Saturday show at the Moose Lodge from 9 AM to 3 PM.
See every upcoming card show by date
First time at a show? Our guide to attending your first card show covers what to bring, and tips for selling at card shows covers the other side of the table.
FAQ
Where can I sell cards in Indianapolis?
Paradigm Games on North Meridian buys at the counter, and Gray Gauntlet Games and Next Level Games in Carmel post buylists, with Gray Gauntlet also taking bulk Magic and Pokémon. For sports cards, Indy Card Exchange, K & L Cards in Greenwood and Vintage Indy Sports in Speedway all buy. k0s Card Shop in Avon buys at set times, but not on Sundays. None of them post a rate, so ask what percentage of market price they pay before you hand anything over. See where to sell Pokémon cards for what to expect.
Which Indianapolis card shops sell Pokémon cards?
k0s Card Shop in Avon runs a three-season Pokémon league, and Grandmaster Games on the south side has a busy league night. Collectors Emporium in Noblesville sells Pokémon singles and graded slabs, and Paradigm Games, Play Test Lounge in Carmel and both Moonshot Games stores carry it too.
Can I get cards graded in Indianapolis?
CardVault by Tom Brady downtown takes PSA, Beckett and SGC submissions in the store. Indy Card Exchange is a PSA Authorized Dealer and can send cards to PSA for you, and Collectors Emporium in Noblesville also takes submissions. See how to ship cards for grading and what grading costs.
Is there a card shop open late in Indianapolis?
Next Level Games in Carmel is open until midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. Play Test Lounge in Carmel is open until 10 PM or later every night, and Good Games downtown and Paradigm Games stay open until 10 PM on some nights.