The Buffalo area has 23 card shops, from Cheektowaga and Amherst out to Niagara Falls, Lockport and the Southtowns in Orchard Park and Hamburg. Dave & Adam’s Card World in Williamsville holds trade nights and athlete autograph signings, Sports Zone 716 in Depew has a large Buffalo Bills selection, and Madhouse Gaming & Hobby in North Tonawanda is open until 11 PM Thursday to Saturday. Each listing has the address, hours, what the shop sells and whether it buys cards, grouped by area.

Jump to: Cheektowaga and Depew · Amherst and Williamsville · Tonawanda and North Tonawanda · West Seneca, Orchard Park and Hamburg · Niagara Falls and Lockport · Card shows

Driving to or through Buffalo? Plan a route through card shops on the way with our trip planner.

Cheektowaga and Depew

A Cardstore

4018 Union Rd, Buffalo 14225 · (716) 713-1184

Hours: Mon 1-7:30 PM, Tue 11 AM-7:30 PM, Wed 1-7:30 PM, Thu 11 AM-7:30 PM, Fri 12-7:30 PM, Sat 11 AM-7:30 PM, Sun 12-5 PM

Sells: Pokémon

Pokémon shop on Union Rd in Cheektowaga selling English and Japanese sealed product. A local show list says it does not sell singles.

Best of One Gaming

2120 George Urban Blvd, Depew 14043 · (716) 473-5025

Sells: Pokémon, Magic

Also: Tournaments

Card game store on George Urban Blvd in Depew with a weekly Pokémon League night. Mostly open evenings, per directory listings.

Heart of the Game

85 S Rossler Ave, Buffalo 14206 · (716) 939-3456

Sells: Magic, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!

Also: Tournaments

Video game store in Cheektowaga that also sells Magic, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards and runs card game events.

Pallet Town Poke Shop

6055 Transit Rd, Depew 14043 · (716) 800-1540

Hours: Tue-Fri 4-8 PM, Sat 1-9 PM, Sun 12-5 PM

Sells: Pokémon, One Piece, Riftbound, Gundam, Digimon, Union Arena, Sports cards

Pokémon-focused shop on Transit Rd selling English and Japanese singles, sealed product and graded cards, plus other card games. Closed Mondays.

Sports Zone 716

5319 Transit Rd, #800, Depew 14043 · (716) 393-3133

Sells: Sports cards, Memorabilia, Pokémon

Owner-run sports card and memorabilia shop on Transit Rd with a large Buffalo Bills selection and some Pokémon.

Top Cut Cards

43 Kelly Dr, Cheektowaga 14227 · (716) 379-6763

Sells: Pokémon

Card game shop on Kelly Dr in Cheektowaga, mainly Pokémon. Open evenings and later on Saturdays, per directory listings.

Amherst and Williamsville

Casual Dragon Games Amherst

3908 Maple Rd, Amherst 14226 · (716) 833-0740

Hours: Mon-Sun 11 AM-7 PM

Sells: Magic, Pokémon

Also: Tournaments

Card and board game store on Maple Rd with Commander nights, prereleases and Magic qualifier events. Has a second store in Lockport.

Dave & Adam's Card World

8075 Sheridan Dr, Williamsville 14221 · (716) 626-0000

Hours: Mon-Thu 11 AM-7 PM, Fri 11 AM-8 PM, Sat 10 AM-8 PM, Sun 10 AM-5 PM

Sells: Sports cards, Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!

Also: Trade nights

Retail store of the Dave & Adam's card business on Sheridan Dr. Holds trade nights and athlete autograph signings; the company also runs a Topps store in Cooperstown.

Great Lakes Sports Cards

4161 Transit Rd, Williamsville 14221 · (716) 580-3180

Sells: Sports cards, Pokémon, Supplies

Also: Buys cards, Breaks

Sports card shop on Transit Rd with vintage cards and Pokémon. Buys and appraises cards and runs breaks.

Hobby Spirit

5639 Harris Hill Rd, Williamsville 14221 · (716) 428-3030

Hours: Tue 12-6 PM, Wed-Sat 12-8 PM, Sun 12-6 PM

Sells: Pokémon, Magic

Shop on Harris Hill Rd selling English and Japanese Pokémon, other card games and board games, with in-store events. Also has a stall at the East Aurora Flea Market on weekends. Closed Mondays.

TCGLegit

5857 Transit Rd, East Amherst 14051 · (716) 458-0041

Hours: Mon-Fri 12-7 PM, Sat 12-4 PM

Sells: Pokémon

Pokémon-focused shop on Transit Rd in East Amherst selling singles, sealed product and graded cards. Closed Sundays.

The Warp Game Store

7806 Transit Rd, Amherst 14221 · (716) 276-8714

Hours: Mon-Thu 11 AM-9 PM, Fri-Sat 11 AM-10 PM, Sun 12-8 PM

Sells: Magic, Pokémon, Gundam, Riftbound

Also: Tournaments

Game store on Transit Rd selling Magic, Pokémon (including Japanese), Gundam and Riftbound alongside Warhammer. Runs prereleases and is open until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

Tonawanda and North Tonawanda

Madhouse Gaming & Hobby

1089 Kinkead Ave, Suite 105, North Tonawanda 14120 · (716) 777-3201

Hours: Mon-Wed 4-9 PM, Thu-Fri 2-11 PM, Sat 11 AM-11 PM, Sun 12-7 PM

Sells: Pokémon, Magic

Game and hobby store on Kinkead Ave selling Pokémon, Bandai card games and other TCGs as sealed product, slabs and singles. Open until 11 PM Thursday to Saturday.

Mana Bar

267 Oliver St, North Tonawanda 14120 · (716) 695-2051

Sells: Magic, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece

Also: Tournaments

Card game store on Oliver St with a large play space, selling Magic, Pokémon and other card games.

Professor Sam's Card Shop

2468 Niagara Falls Blvd, Suite 2, Tonawanda 14150

Sells: Pokémon, Magic

Also: Tournaments

Small card shop on Niagara Falls Blvd with Pokémon League play, singles and sealed product.

Western New York Collectibles

102 Broad St, Tonawanda 14150 · (716) 957-3085

Sells: Sports cards, Memorabilia

Upstairs shop on Broad St in the City of Tonawanda selling sports cards and memorabilia along with toys and video games.

West Seneca, Orchard Park and Hamburg

510 Toy Shop and Sports Cards

6165 W Quaker St, Orchard Park 14127 · (716) 740-8041

Hours: Mon 11 AM-6 PM, Wed-Thu 11 AM-6 PM, Fri 11 AM-7 PM, Sat 10 AM-7 PM, Sun 10 AM-5 PM

Sells: Sports cards, Pokémon

Toy and sports card shop in Orchard Park village with English and Japanese Pokémon. Closed Tuesdays, and opens early on Bills home game days.

716 Sports Cards & Collectibles

1026 Union Rd, West Seneca 14224 · (716) 608-6164

Sells: Sports cards, Pokémon

Sports card and Pokémon shop on Union Rd in West Seneca.

Breakcity Cards & Memorabilia

4408 Milestrip Rd, Blasdell 14219 · (716) 322-5550

Hours: Mon-Sun 11 AM-8 PM

Sells: Sports cards, Pokémon, Memorabilia, Supplies

Also: Buys cards

Sports card and Pokémon shop in the BJ's plaza on Milestrip Rd, open every day until 8 PM. Buys collections.

Game On Sports Memorabilia Southtowns

47 Buffalo St, Hamburg 14075 · (716) 331-6735

Sells: Sports cards, Memorabilia

Village of Hamburg shop on Buffalo St selling sports cards and signed collectibles alongside video games. A Southtowns sister store to Game On!! in Rochester.

Niagara Falls and Lockport

Casual Dragon Games Lockport

136 Walnut St, Lockport 14094 · (716) 201-1147

Sells: Magic, Pokémon

Also: Tournaments

Lockport store of Casual Dragon Games, with card game events and board games. The Amherst store is the larger of the two.

Golden Saucer Gaming

2041 Military Rd, Niagara Falls 14304

Sells: Pokémon, Magic

Small Military Rd storefront that mixes retro and Japanese video games with Pokémon singles, graded slabs and sealed product, plus Magic. Hours vary, so check before going. Runs the Golden Saucer Gaming Expo card show at the outlet mall.

Niagara Sports Cards

4615 Military Rd, Niagara Falls 14305 · (716) 524-2020

Hours: Tue-Fri 10 AM-6 PM, Sat 10 AM-5 PM

Sells: Sports cards

Also: Buys cards

Sports card shop on Military Rd in the Town of Niagara that says it is always buying. Closed Sundays and Mondays.

Shop details checked November 2026. Hours change, so check with the shop before you go.

Buffalo card shows

Buffalo Trading Card Con fills the Buffalo Powerhouse Event Center once a year for Pokémon, Magic, One Piece and other card games. Golden Saucer Gaming runs a one-day Pokémon and card expo at the Fashion Outlets of Niagara Falls USA several times a year, and the Real Deal Buffalo Sports Card & Memorabilia Show, a two-day sports card and autograph show, is at The Grapevine in Depew. Game On Sports Memorabilia Southtowns in Hamburg is a sister store of Game On!!, which is on our Rochester page. Dates move, so check each show’s site before you go.

  • Golden Saucer Gaming Expo Next: Dec 5 · Fashion Outlets of Niagara Falls USA, 1900 Military Rd, Niagara Falls. One-day gaming and card expo at the outlet mall, 10 AM-5 PM, with about 30 vendors selling Pokémon singles, slabs and art. Run by Golden Saucer Gaming; an earlier edition ran in August 2026.
  • Real Deal Buffalo Sports Card & Memorabilia Show Next: Mar 20-21, 2027 · The Grapevine Banquet & Event Center, 333 Dick Rd, Depew. Two-day sports card and memorabilia show that the organizer calls its first. Autograph guests are linked from the organizer's site.
  • Buffalo Trading Card Con · Buffalo Powerhouse Event Center, 140 Lee St, Buffalo. Multi-day convention for Pokémon, Magic, One Piece and other card games. The last edition ran Nov 13-15, 2026; the organizer has not posted the next date.

See every upcoming card show by date

First time at a show? Our guide to attending your first card show covers what to bring, and tips for selling at card shows covers the other side of the table.

FAQ

Where can I sell cards in Buffalo?

Great Lakes Sports Cards in Williamsville buys and appraises cards, Breakcity Cards & Memorabilia in Blasdell buys collections, and Niagara Sports Cards on Military Rd in Niagara Falls says it is always buying. None of the game stores we list say they buy cards. Ask what percentage of market price they pay before you hand anything over. See where to sell Pokémon cards for what to expect.

Which Buffalo card shops sell Pokémon cards?

Most of the shops here carry Pokémon. Pallet Town Poke Shop in Depew and TCGLegit in East Amherst sell singles, sealed product and graded cards, A Cardstore on Union Rd in Cheektowaga sells English and Japanese sealed product, and Golden Saucer Gaming in Niagara Falls mixes Pokémon singles and slabs with retro and Japanese video games.

Can I get cards graded in Buffalo?

We didn’t find a Buffalo shop that takes grading submissions, so you’ll need to mail cards in. Great Lakes Sports Cards in Williamsville appraises cards, which helps you decide what is worth sending, and Pallet Town Poke Shop, TCGLegit and Madhouse Gaming & Hobby sell cards that are already graded. See how to ship cards for grading and what grading costs.

Is there a card shop open late in Buffalo?

Madhouse Gaming & Hobby in North Tonawanda is open until 11 PM Thursday to Saturday and until 9 PM Monday to Wednesday. The Warp Game Store in Amherst is open until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays and until 9 PM Monday to Thursday, and Pallet Town Poke Shop in Depew is open until 9 PM on Saturdays.