The Rochester area has 13 card shops, from the Neighborhood of the Arts and West Ave out to Greece, Spencerport, Webster and Phelps in Ontario County. Yankee Clipper House of Cards in Village Gate Square has been buying and selling cards since 1982, WeTheHobby on Arlington St has a studio for live breaks, and Millennium Games in Henrietta hosts dozens of card game events a week. Each listing has the address, hours, what the shop sells and whether it buys cards, grouped by area.
Jump to: Rochester · Greece, Spencerport and Brockport · Henrietta and Penfield · Webster · Phelps · Card shows
Driving to or through Rochester? Plan a route through card shops on the way with our trip planner.
Rochester
Comics Etc.
1115 E Main St, Door 8, Rochester 14609 · (585) 473-7150
Hours: Mon 12-4 PM, Tue 12-6 PM, Wed 11 AM-6:30 PM, Thu 11 AM-7 PM, Fri 12-6 PM, Sat 11 AM-5 PM, Sun 12-5 PM
Comic shop open since 1983 that also stocks sports cards, non-sports cards, card sets and collectible game cards. Open seven days.
Rochester CCG
801 West Ave, Suite 130, Rochester 14611 · (585) 454-9087
Trading card game store on West Ave selling singles and sealed product across many games. Runs regular events and breaks.
WeTheHobby
23 Arlington St, Rochester 14607 · (585) 730-5819
Hours: Mon-Wed 12-6 PM, Thu-Fri 12-8 PM, Sat 11 AM-8 PM, Sun 11 AM-6 PM
Sports card lounge in the Neighborhood of the Arts with Topps, Panini and Upper Deck product and a studio for live breaks. Offers PSA and CGC grading submissions, consignment and a buyback program, and hosts trade nights.
Yankee Clipper House of Cards
274 N Goodman St, Suite B125, Rochester 14607 · (585) 442-5700
Hours: Wed-Sat 11 AM-5 PM
Vintage and modern card shop in Village Gate Square that has been buying, selling and trading since 1982. Also sells toys and other collectibles; closed Sunday to Tuesday.
Greece, Spencerport and Brockport
Game On!!
2670 Dewey Ave, Rochester 14616 · (585) 481-2153
Hours: Tue-Thu 10 AM-7 PM, Fri 12-7 PM, Sat 11 AM-4 PM
Video game and sports memorabilia store on Dewey Ave near the Greece line that also sells sports cards. Closed Sundays and Mondays.
In The Zone
162 Greece Ridge Center Dr, Rochester 14626 · (585) 723-0570
Sports memorabilia store in The Mall at Greece Ridge selling cards alongside posters and team clothing.
JC's Cards and Collectibles
24 West Ave, Spencerport 14559 · (585) 694-0111
Hours: Mon 1-3 PM, Wed 1-4 PM, Fri-Sat 1:30-4 PM, Sun 1-4 PM
Small sports card shop in the village of Spencerport with modern cards, hobby boxes and supplies. Buys, sells and trades; open short afternoon hours.
Leone's Collectibles
612 Stone Rd, Rochester 14616 · (585) 865-4260
Collectibles dealer on Stone Rd in Greece selling baseball and basketball cards and sets alongside back-issue magazines, vinyl, action figures and sports memorabilia. Its own site runs as Mr-Magazine; call ahead for hours.
Henrietta and Penfield
Just Games Rochester
1601 Penfield Rd, Suite 34, Rochester 14625 · (585) 586-0586
Hours: Mon-Sat 12-9 PM, Sun 12-6 PM
Board, card and role-playing game store in Penfield with a busy Magic event calendar, including Commander. Buys card game singles.
Millennium Games
1225 Jefferson Rd, Rochester 14623 · (585) 427-2190
Hours: Mon-Sat 10 AM-10 PM, Sun 10 AM-6 PM
Large game store on Jefferson Rd in Henrietta that bills itself as the largest game store in the country. Hosts dozens of card game events a week and is open until 10 PM Monday to Saturday.
Webster
Gametopia
1900 Empire Blvd, Suite 817, Webster 14580 · (585) 280-3416
Hours: Mon-Fri 1-10 PM, Sat-Sun 10 AM-10 PM
Game store on Empire Blvd selling Magic and Pokémon singles, board games and Warhammer, with drinks and regular events. Open until 10 PM every day.
Legacy Games
1028 Ridge Rd, Suite 112, Webster 14580 · (585) 866-4263
Hours: Mon-Sat 11 AM-9:30 PM, Sun 12-7 PM
Card, video and tabletop game store on Ridge Rd with card singles, gaming rooms and an events calendar. Open until 9:30 PM Monday to Saturday.
Phelps
Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles
256 Main St, Phelps 14532 · (315) 548-2354
Hours: Mon 10 AM-6 PM, Wed-Fri 10 AM-6 PM, Sat 10 AM-5 PM, Sun 10 AM-4 PM
Sports card and memorabilia shop in the village of Phelps in Ontario County. Runs breaks and rip nights, buys vintage cards and hosts an annual Christmas card show; closed Tuesdays.
Shop details checked November 2026. Hours change, so check with the shop before you go.
Rochester card shows
CollectorFest Monthly is a free Sunday show at the JCC on Edgewood Ave with sports cards, Pokémon and other non-sport cards, and it has run almost every month since 2001. Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles holds its Christmas Card Show at the Phelps Community Center each December, with more than 60 tables. West along the Thruway, we list shops around Buffalo. Downstate, we also list shops in New York City and on Long Island. Dates move, so check each show’s site before you go.
- CollectorFest Monthly Next: Nov 22 · Louis S. Wolk JCC of Greater Rochester, 1200 Edgewood Ave, Rochester. Free Sunday show, 10 AM-2 PM, with sports cards, Pokémon and other non-sport cards plus some comics, coins and wrestling items. The organizer says it has run every month since June 2001 apart from a few pandemic months.
- Diamond Club Christmas Card Show Next: Dec 12 · Phelps Community Center gym, 8 Banta St, Phelps. Annual pre-Christmas show run by Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles, with 60+ tables. The Dec 12, 2026 edition runs 9:30 AM-2:30 PM.
See every upcoming card show by date
First time at a show? Our guide to attending your first card show covers what to bring, and tips for selling at card shows covers the other side of the table.
FAQ
Where can I sell cards in Rochester?
For sports cards, Yankee Clipper House of Cards and WeTheHobby in Rochester, JC’s Cards and Collectibles in Spencerport and Diamond Club Cards & Collectibles in Phelps all buy, and WeTheHobby takes consignment too. For game cards, Just Games Rochester in Penfield buys singles. Ask what percentage of market price they pay before you hand anything over. See where to sell Pokémon cards for what to expect.
Which Rochester card shops sell Pokémon cards?
Rochester CCG on West Ave, Millennium Games in Henrietta, and Legacy Games and Gametopia in Webster all carry Pokémon. Gametopia sells Pokémon singles and is open until 10 PM every day.
Can I get cards graded in Rochester?
WeTheHobby in Rochester takes PSA and CGC grading submissions. See how to ship cards for grading and what grading costs.
Is there a card shop open late in Rochester?
Gametopia in Webster is open until 10 PM every day, and Millennium Games in Henrietta until 10 PM Monday to Saturday. Legacy Games in Webster stays open until 9:30 PM and Just Games Rochester in Penfield until 9 PM, both Monday to Saturday.
