Long Island has 39 card shops across Nassau and Suffolk, from Elmont and Valley Stream out to Center Moriches and East Hampton. Card Shack near Lynbrook station has sold sports cards for more than 25 years, The Comic Book Depot in Wantagh has run since 1993, and Max Rarity in Valley Stream is open late every night. Each listing has the address, hours, what the shop sells and whether it buys cards, grouped by area.
Jump to: Mineola, Port Washington and Glen Cove · Lynbrook, Valley Stream and Oceanside · Westbury, Merrick and Massapequa · Commack, Deer Park and Bay Shore · Patchogue, Ronkonkoma and the East End · Card shows
Driving to or through Long Island? Plan a route through card shops on the way with our trip planner.
Mineola, Port Washington and Glen Cove
528 Collectibles
135 Birch Hill Rd, Locust Valley 11560 · (516) 490-0697
Hours: Sun-Tue 11-4, Wed-Sat 11-7
Card shop in Locust Valley, one of three 528 Collectibles stores (the others are in Massachusetts and North Carolina). It sells singles and boxes, runs box breaks and takes grading submissions.
Filthbomb Breaks
116 Glen St, Glen Cove 11542 · (518) 267-3010
Hours: Tue-Fri 12-7, Sat 10-5
Card shop in downtown Glen Cove built around live breaks, with sports cards and Pokémon. Closed Sundays and Mondays per its own site.
Long Island Sports Cards
1013 Willis Ave, Albertson 11507 · (516) 636-1013
Hours: Tue-Thu 11-6, Fri-Sat 11-7, Sun 12-4
Sports card shop on Willis Ave in Albertson with no website. Closed Mondays.
Major Sports Cards
466 Jericho Tpke, Mineola 11501 · (516) 240-2415
Hours: Mon 11-6, Tue-Fri 11-7, Sat 11-5, Sun 11-3
Sports card shop on Jericho Turnpike in Mineola that also stocks Pokémon and One Piece. Open seven days, with short Sunday hours.
Shoreline Sports Cards
137 Main St, Port Washington 11050 · (516) 813-8551
Sports card shop on Main St in Port Washington that also carries Pokémon. It buys cards and runs breaks.
Lynbrook, Valley Stream and Oceanside
A Store of Fire & Dice
486 Merrick Rd, Lynbrook 11563 · (516) 812-5099
Hours: Mon-Fri 2-11:30 PM, Sat-Sun 1-7
Game store on Merrick Rd in Lynbrook focused on Magic and other card games. Open until 11:30 PM on weeknights.
Card Shack
9 Atlantic Ave, Lynbrook 11563 · (516) 561-5100
Hours: Mon-Fri 10-7, Sat 10-6, Sun 11-3
Long-running sports card shop near Lynbrook station that also stocks Pokémon. Upper Deck has profiled it for its 25 years in the hobby.
DZCollectibles Long Island
2833 Long Beach Rd, Oceanside 11572 · (516) 399-7700
Hours: Mon-Thu 2-7, Fri 2-11 PM, Sat 12-11 PM, Sun 12-6
Card shop on Long Beach Rd in Oceanside with Pokémon, sports cards and several other card games. Open until 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Heirloom Hobby
98 Sheridan Blvd, Inwood 11096 · (516) 708-3222
Card shop in Inwood with sports cards, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh! and One Piece, and live breaks.
Max Rarity
175 Rockaway Ave, Valley Stream 11580 · (845) 272-2428
Hours: Mon-Fri 3-11 PM, Sat 12-11 PM, Sun 2-10 PM
Game store in Valley Stream for Magic, One Piece and Pokémon, with prerelease events. Open late every night.
Revolution Cards
1303 Hempstead Tpke, Elmont 11003 · (516) 302-8114
Card game shop on Hempstead Turnpike in Elmont for One Piece, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh!.
Rip It Card Co
534 Willow Ave, Cedarhurst 11516 · (516) 699-3028
Hours: Sun-Thu 11-7, Fri 11-4
Sports card shop in Cedarhurst that buys, sells and takes grading submissions. Closed Saturdays.
Westbury, Merrick and Massapequa
A & S Sports
825 Carman Ave, Westbury 11590 · (516) 414-4323
Hours: Mon-Thu 10-5, Fri-Sat 10-6, Sun 10-4
Sports card shop on Carman Ave in Westbury. Open seven days.
Bullseye Collectibles
1826 Merrick Rd, Merrick 11566 · (516) 379-8300
Hours: Tue-Wed 11-5, Thu 12-7, Fri 11-8, Sat 11-5, Sun 11-4
Sports card and Pokémon shop on Merrick Rd. Closed Mondays.
Everyone's Gaming Outlet
2731 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown 11756 · (516) 462-1592
Tabletop and card game store on Hempstead Turnpike in Levittown, with play events every day of the week. It also sells Warhammer and board games.
Lost4Toys
267 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South 11530
Family-run comics, toys and collectibles shop that moved from West Hempstead to Nassau Blvd in late 2025. Its card stock covers Pokémon, Magic, Lorcana and sports cards.
Mid Island Collectibles
358 N Broadway, Suite 460, Hicksville 11801
Pokémon-focused card shop inside the Broadway Mall in Hicksville. It hosted a weekly Thursday card and tabletop game night through summer 2026.
Prime 151 Collectibles
742 N Broadway, Massapequa 11758 · (516) 384-5430
Hours: Mon 10-10, Tue-Wed 10-8, Thu 10-10, Fri-Sat 10-8, Sun 12-6
Card shop in North Massapequa with Pokémon, sports cards and several other games, plus comics. Open until 10 PM on Monday and Thursday gaming nights; collection evaluations are by appointment.
The Comic Book Depot
2847 Jerusalem Ave, Wantagh 11793 · (516) 221-9337
Hours: Mon-Fri 1-10 PM, Sat-Sun 12-7
Comic shop on Jerusalem Ave in Wantagh, open since 1993, with a big card game side: sealed product, singles and weekly events. Open until 10 PM on weeknights.
Commack, Deer Park and Bay Shore
Cardboard Memories
114 Commack Rd, Commack 11725 · (631) 462-1919
Hours: Mon-Wed 10-6, Thu-Fri 10-7, Sat 10-6, Sun 11-5
Sports card shop on Commack Rd that also stocks Pokémon and handles PSA submissions. Open seven days.
East End Gaming
4580 Sunrise Hwy, Oakdale 11769 · (631) 750-3679
Hours: Mon-Tue 12-7, Wed 12-11, Thu 12-7, Fri 12-12, Sat 12-7, Sun 12-5
Large game store on Sunrise Hwy in Oakdale with card game events. Open late on Wednesday and Friday event nights.
Gotham City Hobbies
70 Route 109, West Babylon 11704 · (631) 526-9404
Hobby shop on Route 109 in West Babylon that carries Pokémon and One Piece.
Grand Slam Collectibles (North Babylon)
1204 Deer Park Ave, North Babylon 11703 · (631) 574-1800
Main store of a Long Island chain of sports card and memorabilia shops, which also has stores in Selden, Bellport and Commack. It also stocks Pokémon and hosts signings.
Retro Island Gaming
87B Carleton Ave, Islip Terrace 11752 · (631) 650-1504
Hours: Sun-Mon 11-9, Wed-Sat 11-9
Video game store in Islip Terrace that also carries Pokémon, Lorcana, Flesh and Blood and Yu-Gi-Oh!. Closed Tuesdays; Sunday hours differ between sources.
Rip N Ship Gaming
1883 Deer Park Ave Unit B, Deer Park 11729 · (631) 667-0381
Hours: Mon-Thu 12-11, Fri 12-12, Sat 12-10, Sun 12-8
Game store on Deer Park Ave with play space for Magic, Pokémon and many other card games. Open until midnight on Fridays.
Smoke and Mirrors Hobby
3 Brandywine Dr, Deer Park 11729 · (631) 479-4031
Hobby and game store in Deer Park carrying Pokémon, Magic, One Piece and Lorcana.
TCG Depot
10 E Main St, East Islip 11730 · (631) 650-0619
Card game shop on Main St in East Islip.
The Gaming Corner
322 W Montauk Hwy, Store C, Lindenhurst 11757 · (631) 866-7191
Hours: Mon-Thu 2-8, Fri 2-9, Sat 2-8, Sun 12-5
Game store on Montauk Hwy in Lindenhurst for Magic, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh!. Listings show a second location in Westbury.
Patchogue, Ronkonkoma and the East End
Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles
1244 Middle Country Rd, Selden 11784 · (631) 698-2805
Game store on Middle Country Rd in Selden for Yu-Gi-Oh!, Pokémon, Magic and Dragon Ball, plus board games.
CardVault by Tom Brady (East Hampton)
47 Newtown Ln, East Hampton 11937 · (631) 931-7151
East Hampton branch of the CardVault chain, opened in May 2025. It is the only card shop found on the East End.
Funky Town Collectibles
2394 Middle Country Rd, Centereach 11720 · (631) 615-1817
Hours: Mon-Sat 10-5:30, Sun 12-5
Collectibles shop on Middle Country Rd in Centereach with Pokémon, sports cards and other card games, plus toys.
Genesis Comics and Gaming
600-26 Portion Rd, Lake Ronkonkoma 11779 · (631) 471-4855
Comic and game store on Portion Rd with Magic singles, Pokémon, Lorcana and sports cards. A second Genesis store is in Patchogue.
Genesis Comics and Gaming (Patchogue)
580 Medford Ave, Patchogue 11772 · (631) 472-0250
Second Genesis store, on Medford Ave in Patchogue, in the space Brendan's Sports Cards used to occupy. Its own site says this store carries comics and sports cards.
Grand Slam Collectibles (Bellport)
10 Farber Dr, Suite 7, Bellport 11713 · (631) 574-1800
Bellport store of the Grand Slam Collectibles chain. A listing says it holds Saturday Pokémon trade nights and monthly Topps rip nights.
Grand Slam Collectibles (Selden)
247 Middle Country Rd, Selden 11784 · (631) 574-1800
Selden store of the Grand Slam Collectibles chain, with sports cards, memorabilia and Pokémon.
MetaGames.Toys
567 Route 25A, Rocky Point 11778 · (631) 800-2013
Hours: Mon 1-6, Tue-Thu 1-10 PM, Fri 1 PM-12 AM, Sat-Sun 1-6
Game and toy store on Route 25A in Rocky Point that runs Magic nights. Open until midnight on Fridays.
New York Card Marketplace
2468 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven 11719 · (631) 803-0500
Card shop on Montauk Hwy in Brookhaven that opened in March 2026, focused on Pokémon including Japanese product, with sports cards and live breaks.
Super Sport Cards
383 Main St, Unit D, Center Moriches 11934 · (631) 878-4807
Hours: Wed-Thu 1-6, Fri 4-9, Sat-Sun 1-6
Sports card shop on Main St in Center Moriches. Closed Mondays and Tuesdays.
The Card Collective NY
202 E Main St, Patchogue 11772
Pokémon-focused card shop on Main St in Patchogue. Listings disagree on hours.
Shop details checked November 2026. Hours change, so check with the shop before you go.
Long Island card shows
The LI TCG Show Marketplace sets up at the Hilton in Melville two or three times a month, and the Long Island TCG Show comes to Nassau Coliseum in the spring. For Queens, Brooklyn and Manhattan shops and shows, see our New York City page. Dates move, so check each show’s site before you go.
- LI TCG Show Marketplace Next: Nov 27 · Hilton Long Island/Huntington, Melville. Smaller one-day TCG marketplace from the Long Island TCG Show team, held one to three times a month at the Hilton in Melville.
- Long Island TCG Show Next: May 1-2, 2027 · Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, Uniondale. Long Island's largest trading card game show, a two-day weekend in Uniondale. The 2026 edition ran May 2-3 at Nassau Coliseum.
See every upcoming card show by date
First time at a show? Our guide to attending your first card show covers what to bring, and tips for selling at card shows covers the other side of the table.
FAQ
Where can I sell cards on Long Island?
For sports cards, Card Shack in Lynbrook, Rip It Card Co in Cedarhurst, Shoreline in Port Washington and the Grand Slam stores buy. For Pokémon and other games, DZCollectibles in Oceanside, Prime 151 in Massapequa, Filthbomb Breaks in Glen Cove and 528 Collectibles in Locust Valley buy too. Ask what percentage of market price they pay before you hand anything over. See where to sell Pokémon cards for what to expect.
Which Long Island card shops sell Pokémon cards?
The Card Collective NY in Patchogue, Mid Island Collectibles in the Broadway Mall and TCG Depot in East Islip focus on Pokémon. New York Card Marketplace in Brookhaven stocks Japanese Pokémon, and the Grand Slam store in Bellport holds Saturday Pokémon trade nights.
Can I get cards graded on Long Island?
Cardboard Memories in Commack handles PSA submissions. Card Shack, Rip It Card Co, A & S Sports in Westbury, Prime 151, 528 Collectibles and New York Card Marketplace take grading submissions too. See how to ship cards for grading and what grading costs.
Is there a card shop open late on Long Island?
Rip N Ship Gaming in Deer Park, East End Gaming in Oakdale and MetaGames.Toys in Rocky Point are open until midnight on Fridays. A Store of Fire & Dice in Lynbrook stays open until 11:30 PM on weeknights, Max Rarity in Valley Stream until 11 PM most nights, and The Comic Book Depot in Wantagh until 10 PM on weekdays.
